“Lmao, does anyone actually buy this?”
That was the title of a post on r/MicrosoftFlightSim this week, aimed at Flightsim.to’s Premium tier. The poster, u/_Dsync_, was nicer about it in the body: “Dont wanna hate and flightsim.to is actually a great website but was this necessary?”
The comments weren’t as nice. I commented too, for what it’s worth.
Prices
As of 9 October:
- 3-day trial: €3.95
- One month, one-off: €11
- Three months, one-off: €28.95, labelled “Save 15%”
- Monthly subscription: €10, labelled “Best Value”
Three single months add up to €33. €28.95 is about 12% less than that. Not 15.
The three-month pack also comes to €9.65 a month, so it’s cheaper than the “Best Value” option.
There’s no yearly plan.
Premium removes the ads, countdown and captchas, gives you faster downloads, and adds unlimited saved searches, Pushover notifications and store coupons. The one-click installer is locked behind Premium too.
Free downloads
Flightsim.to puts its own free vs. Premium table on the same page. Free users get “500 KB/s to 5 MB/s”, with an average of 150 users sharing the same bandwidth. Premium gets “50 MB/s +” with 20 users. Free users also wait 5 to 25 seconds per download and start getting captchas after 20 downloads.
That’s not what Flightsim.to wrote when Premium launched on 11 February 2023:
“There will be no limitations on downloads or other restrictions for non-Premium users, including no throttling or speed caps or anything similar.”
The same post said Premium was there “to support the cost of our servers and hosting needs” and that pricing had been kept “accessible where possible”.
Flightsim.to could argue that this isn’t technically a speed cap: Premium users get access to a faster server network. Fine. But the 2023 promise wasn’t just about speed. It said there would be “no limitations on downloads or other restrictions”. A countdown is a restriction. So is throwing a captcha at you after 20 files.
I tried it as a free user. The countdown ran 15 seconds before the download started. Not a big deal on its own, but it’s there on every file.
“Do you think all that storage and bandwidth is free?”
That was u/-FlyingAce-, and plenty of the thread agreed.
“There are costs for the traffic, bandwidth and storage of all those files,” wrote u/gotBurner. u/edilclyde, a systems engineer, pays for it: €10 a month “to support that cause without me having to see ads is okay in my book.”
u/BeetlecatOne didn’t buy it. “actual storage costs are negligible. Bandwidth does take a bite, Yes, but they also put ads everywhere.” u/j_shor said he does this for a living, and that hosting a site like this is “not that big” a cost if it’s built right.
Flightsim.to’s advertiser page says it has 500,000 monthly active users, more than 100,000 add-ons and more than 100 million downloads. One commenter put ad income at around $13,000 a month against more than $25,000 in costs, and called it “very rough”.
I tried some back-of-an-envelope maths. Flightsim.to says it has passed 100 million downloads. Hangar Addons’ counter currently works out to about 230 MB per download. At a few million downloads a month, that quickly turns into hundreds of terabytes of traffic.
Depending on the CDN, that could cost anything from a few thousand dollars to well into five figures. bunny.net would be towards the lower end. AWS CloudFront gets expensive fast. Cloudflare R2 doesn’t charge egress at all.
I don’t know which setup Flightsim.to actually uses, so the maths can’t tell us much more than that. Its 2023 post only says Premium users get access to the “more-expensive” network.
Then the inevitable Nexus Mods comparison.
Nexus has charged €8.39 a month or €83.99 a year, excluding tax, since June 2024. It’s a much bigger site, and it has a yearly plan.
u/welding-guy: “I would happily pay $10 per annum but use the free access instead because their offers are way to expensive.”
Whose content?
Flightsim.to didn’t make the liveries, GSX profiles or scenery anyone downloads there. Creators upload them for free. The site charges for faster access to their work.
That’s what blew up in 2023. Premium launched alongside a Creators Program and terms that gave the site a “royalty-free, perpetual, irrevocable” licence to uploads, plus this clause: “We reserve the right to keep your User Content indefinitely and are not obligated to remove it.”
KL791, Emerald Scenery Design and Got Friends pulled out. Got Friends later said Flightsim.to had ended the partnership. Within days, Flightsim.to floated a compromise: deletion on request, after waiting periods of 7 to 60 days.
“You should have been there when they introduced it,” u/TheRealPomax wrote this week. “You’ve never seen a community that angry.”
AVSIM never charged
Before Flightsim.to there was AVSIM. Tom Allensworth started it in 1996. It’s a nonprofit run by volunteers, and as far as I can tell, its library has never charged for a download. Ads and donations paid for the bandwidth and hardware.
In May 2009 a hacker wiped both of its servers. There was no external backup. Rebuilding cost around $25,000, and donors and advertisers covered most of it. By late July the library was back to more than 95% of its files.
So why charge now?
The obvious answer is file size. FS9 and FSX add-ons were small. An MSFS livery with 4K textures can run to hundreds of megabytes.
One scenery I checked, OKKK Kuwait International Airport and City, is 1.4 GB on its own.
Bandwidth is also far cheaper than it was back then. When Amazon launched CloudFront in November 2008, data transfer in the US started at $0.17 per GB. Today it’s $0.085 after the first free terabyte, and bunny.net charges a cent or less.
And when AVSIM needed $25,000, it asked. People paid.
AVSIM’s library never made the jump to MSFS, though. It does have an MSFS 2020 section, opened in September 2020, but as a library admin put it back then, files only appear “when an author CHOOSES to have one here.”
In a 2021 thread, one user said it took “more or less two days” to get a single file approved. In February 2023 an admin wrote that the library server was down, with “No estimate for when it’ll be returned to service.”
It’s still there, and still free. The library holds 149,103 files and gets new uploads every day, mostly FS2004 and FSX repaints and AI flight plans. The MSFS section has a little over 500 files in the subcategories I could open. Flightsim.to says it has more than 100,000 add-ons. Of AVSIM’s 100 most downloaded files over the past 30 days, not one was for MSFS.
AVSIM didn’t lose MSFS to a better price. Both were free. It lost to a site where an upload went live straight away, not two days later.
So is it fair to charge?
For hosting, yes.
Several hundred terabytes a month isn’t free, and somebody has to run the place. If the bills really are $25,000 a month, 2,500 subscribers cover them. That’s half a percent of the users Flightsim.to says it has.
The pricing is another matter.
Flightsim.to said in 2023 there would be no speed caps or download restrictions. Today its own table starts free users at 500 KB/s and adds countdowns and captchas.
The “Save 15%” offer saves about 12%. And there’s no yearly plan, which is where Nexus gets cheap: €83.99 a year works out to about €7 a month before tax.
And the thing you’re paying to download faster was, in most cases, made by somebody else and uploaded for free.
Hangar Addons
A few people in the thread pointed to Hangar Addons. It launched in September and is run by Michael Geise, who built the Need for Speed mod site NFSCars, now NFSAddons.
There are no ads for now, just a donate button. Geise says any future ads would sit inline, with no timers or pop-ups.
Its counter on 9 October: 298 add-ons, 3,547 downloads, 816.2 GB transferred.
Small.
Got Friends is there, with the Fokker Dr.1 and the Discus-2c Standard.
“The download speeds aren’t throttled which is really nice,” wrote u/shortairbus.
Give it 100 million downloads and we’ll see.










